Over time, I’ve explored several books on mental models, biases, and decision-making. Among them, Clear Thinking by Shane Parrish stood out for its clarity and practicality. It offers a straightforward step-by-step framework, making complex ideas easier to apply. 

I’m writing this post primarily as a self-reference for future use, but I hope others find it equally helpful.

Here’s the simple, actionable decision-making framework anyone can follow, as outlined in the book 

1. Define the Problem

“To understand is to know what to do.” – Ludwig Wittgenstein

Most of us rush to solve problems without pausing to define them clearly. Often, what appears to be the problem is merely a symptom. Solving the symptom might give short-term relief, but the real issue remains unresolved.

Steps to Define the Problem:

• Clarify Your Goal: Start by asking, What do I want to achieve?
• Identify Obstacles: Next, ask, What’s standing in my way?
• Apply Two Key Principles:
  1. The Definition Principle: Don’t let others define the problem for you. Do the work yourself, and avoid jargon.
  2. The Root Cause Principle: Dig deeper to find the root cause by asking, What should be true for this problem to not exist?

Safeguards:

• Build a Problem-Solution Firewall: Separate problem definition from solution discussions. Hold/Think in two different meetings if necessary.
• Use the Test of Time: After defining the problem, sleep on it. If the definition still makes sense the next day, you’re on the right track.

2. Explore Possible Solutions

Once you have a well-defined problem, it’s time to explore solutions. The key here is to avoid binary thinking and ensure you’re considering multiple possibilities.

Principles for Solution Exploration:

• The 3+ Principle: Force yourself to come up with at least three potential solutions.
• The Bad Outcome Principle: Don’t just imagine the ideal outcome. Think about what could go wrong and how you’ll address it.
• The Second-Level Thinking Principle: Always ask, And then what? Consider the second-order consequences of your decisions.
• Both-And Thinking: Instead of choosing between two options, find ways to integrate them.

Safeguards:

• Imagine Alternatives Off the Table: For each option, ask yourself, What would I do if this option weren’t possible?
• Think Through Opportunity Costs: Use the 3-Lens Principle:
  1. Compared with what?
  2. And then what?
  3. At the expense of what?

3. Evaluate the Options

With multiple solutions on the table, the next step is to evaluate them against clear criteria. The goal is to select the option that best promotes your objective while considering both short-term and long-term consequences.

Criteria for Evaluation:

• Clarity: Ensure your criteria are simple and free of jargon.
• Goal Promotion: Favor options that directly achieve your desired outcome.
• Decisiveness: The criteria must help you select one clear winner.

Techniques for Better Evaluation:

• Assign quantitative values to your criteria. Think in terms of costs and benefits—whether in time, money, or resources.
• The Targeting Principle: Know what you’re looking for before you start sorting through the data.
• The HiFi Principle: Seek high-fidelity (HiFi) information—close to the source and unfiltered by others.

4. Make the Judgment

Decision-making is not just about gathering information—it’s about knowing when to act.

Principles for Timely Decision-Making:

• The ASAP Principle: If the cost to undo a decision is low, act quickly and learn by doing.
• The ALAP Principle: If the cost to undo a decision is high, take your time and gather as much information as possible.
• The Stop, Flop, Know Principle: Stop deliberating when:
  • You stop gathering useful information.
  • You first lose an opportunity.
  • You come to know something that makes the decision obvious.

Safeguards:

• Build in margins of safety to absorb unexpected setbacks.
• Use fail-safes like trip wires to trigger specific actions when certain thresholds are met.

5. Learn from Your Decisions

Finally, great decision-makers continuously learn from their past decisions. The goal is to refine your process, not just celebrate outcomes.

Principles for Learning:

• The Process Principle: Focus on evaluating your decision-making process, not just the outcome. Good outcomes can result from bad processes (luck), but good processes consistently yield better long-term results.
• The Transparency Principle: Keep a record of your decision-making process. This helps you learn from both successes and failures.

When Getting Information from Others, Ask These 3 Key Questions:

When gathering information from someone else, ask:

1. What variables would you consider if you were in my shoes?
2. What do you know about this problem that I (or other people) don’t?
3. What process would you follow if you were making this decision?

These questions help uncover deeper insights by tapping into others’ unique experiences and perspectives.

Safeguards:

• Distinguish real experts from popularizers/influencers. Expertise comes from depth of knowledge, not just visibility.

Conclusion

So the next time you face a complex decision, pause and ask yourself: Have I truly defined the problem? Then, follow these steps to navigate toward better outcomes, one thoughtful decision at a time.

Please subscribe here to get my latest posts delivered straight to your inbox.